通用竞争战略研究方法论的历史反思——一个基于博弈与约束优化建模的新研究架构

doi:10.12005/orms.2021.0011

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 本文从独特的方法论视角回顾了通用竞争战略实证研究的历史,首次关注了其中的Palepu战略识别假设和战略数理解析的研究,分析了制约其发展的关键方法论问题;评述了近期战略解析建模研究的突破性进展及相关实证研究的进展的新方法论涵义,发现了反传统的理论建构性研究所面临的机遇,预测了通用战略建模、Palepu战略识别假设的解析验证和相关实证研究可能成为研究前沿。最后,提出了一个跨战略管理、财务管理和博弈论-约束优化三个领域的新研究架构设想。

关键词: 综述, 通用竞争战略, 博弈论, 约束优化, DuPont-Palepu财务体系, 战略识别, 方法论

Abstract: This paper reviews the history of empirical research of generic competitive strategies from a unique perspective, and pays attention to the introduction and application of Palepu assumptions for strategy identification and strategic mathematical analysis for the first time. Then, the paper indicates the key problems of in this area. And, it also overviews the breakthrough in the analytical modeling for generic strategies and the advances of relative empirical research, finding the opportunity faced by unconventional theoretical constructive research. Furthermore, the paper forecasts that the game modeling of generic strategies, the analytical verification of Palepu assumptions and its related empirical studies may become a research front. Lastly, we propose the new interdisciplinary research framework for this area which involves strategic management, financial management and game theory.

Key words: review, generic competitive strategies, game theory, constrained optimization, DuPont-Palepu financial systems, strategy identification, methodology

中图分类号:

陈圻. 通用竞争战略研究方法论的历史反思——一个基于博弈与约束优化建模的新研究架构[J]. 运筹与管理, 2021, 30(1): 71-81.

CHEN Qi. A Historical Review for Research Methodology of Generic Competitive Strategies ——A New Research Framework Based on Game-constrained Optimization Modelling[J]. Operations Research and Management Science, 2021, 30(1): 71-81.

参考文献

[1] David J S, et al, The performance effects of congruence between product competitive strategies and purchasing management design[J]. Management science, 2002, 48(7): 866-885.
[2] 陈圻,任娟.一般竞争战略的逻辑基础重构[J].管理学报,2011(8):1146-55.
[3] Ormanidhi O, Stringa O. Porter's model of generic competitive strategies: an insightful and convenient approach to firms' analysis[J]. Business Economics, 2008(7): 55-64.
[4] Rumelt R P, Schendel D, Teece D J. Strategic management and economics[J]. Strategic Management Journal, January, 1991(10): 1002-1025.
[5] Dess G, Peter S, Davis P S. Porter's generic strategies as determinants of strategic group membership and organizational performance[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 1984, 27(9): 467-488.
[6] Spanos Ye, Zaralis G, Lioukas S. Strategy and industry effects on profitability: evidence from greece[J]. Strategic Management Journal, 2004, 25(2): 139-165.
[7] Kim E, Nam D, Stimpert J L. Testing the applicability of porter's generic strategy in the digital age: a study of korean cyber malls[J]. Journal Business Strategy, 2004, 21(1): 19-45.
[8] Spanos Yiannis E, Zaralis George, Lioukas Spyros. Strategy and industry effects on profitability: evidence from greece[J]. Strategic Management Journal, 2004, 25(2): 139-165.
[9] Acquaah M, Yasai-Ardekani M. Does the implementation of a combination competitive strategy yield incremental performance benefits? A new perspective from a transition economy in Sub-Saharan Africa[J]. Journal of Business Research, 2007(6): 21.
[10] Yamin S, et al., A study of competitive strategy, organisational innovation and organisational performance among australian manufacturing companies[J]. International Journal of Production Economics, 1997, 52(1-2): 161-172.
[11] Miller D, Friesen P H, Porter's(1980) generic strategies and performance: an empirical examination with american data, part I: testing porter[J]. Organization Studies, 1986, 7(1): 37-55.
[12] Allen R S, et al. Porter's generic strategies: an exploratory study of their use in Japan[J]. Journal of Business Strategies, 2007, 24(1): 69-89.
[13] Barney J B, Hoskisson R E. Strategic groups: untested assertions and research proposals[J]. Managerial and Decision Economics, 1990, 11(3): 187-198.
[14] Campbell-Hunt Colin. What have we learned about generic competitive strategy? a meta-analysis[J]. Strategic Management Journal, 2000, 21(2): 127-154.
[15] 陈收,潘志强.环境不确定性对竞争战略与企业绩效关系的调节效应[J].中国科技论,2014(2):57-64.
[16] 刘睿智,胥朝阳.竞争战略、企业绩效与持续竞争优势——来自中国上市公司的经验数据[J].科研管理,2008,29(6):36-43.
[17] 雷辉,杨丹.基于创新投入的企业竞争战略对绩效的影响[J].系统工程,2013,31(9):114-119.
[18] 鲍新中,孙晔,陶秋燕,盛晓娟.竞争战略、创新研发与企业绩效的关系研究[J].中国科技论坛,2014(6):63-69.
[19] Nandakumar M K, Ghobadian A, Regan N. Generic strategies and performance evidence from manufacturing firm[J]. International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management, 2011(3): 222-251.
[20] Kaliappen N, Hilman H. Enhancing organizational performance through strategic alignment of cost leadership strategy and competitor orientation[J]. Middle-East Journal of Scientific Research, 18, 2013(10): 1411-1416.
[21] Banker R D, Mashruwala R, Tripathy A. Does a differentiation strategy lead to more sustainable financial performance than a cost leadership strategy[J]. Management Decision 52, 2014 (5): 872-96.
[22] Mintzberg H. Patterns in strategy formulation[J]. Management Science, 1978, 24(4): 934-948.
[23] Fajoun M. Towards an organic perspective on strategy[J]. Strategy Management Journal, 2002, 23(4): 561-594.
[24] Palepu K, Healy P. Business analysis and valuation: using financial statements[M]. Mason, OH: Thomson Southwestern, 4th ed, 2008.
[25] Little Philip L, Little Beverly L, Coffee, David. The DuPont model: evaluating alternative strategies in the retail industry[J]. Academy of Strategic Management Journal, 2009(8): 71-80.
[26] Little P, Mortimer J W, Keene M A, etc. Evaluating the effect of recession on retail firms' strategy using du pont method: 2006~2009[J]. Journal of Finance and Accountancy, 72, 2011(4): 22-26.
[27] Tang Ying-Chan, Liou Fen-May. Does firm performance reveal its own causes? the role of bayesian inference[J]. Strategic Management Journal, 2010, 31(1): 39-57.
[28] 颉茂华,刘斯琴,杨彩霞.产品市场竞争度、竞争战略选择对成本黏性的影响研究[J].产业经济研究,2016(1):11-19.
[29] Hambric D C, MacMillan I C, Day D. Strategic attributes and performance in the BCG matrix-a PIMS-based analysis of industrial product businesses[J]. Academy of Management Journal , 1982, 25(3): 510-531.
[30] David J S, Hwang Y, Pei B K, Reneau W. The performance effects of congruence between product competitive strategies and purchasing management design[J]. Management Science, 2002, 48(4): 866-886.
[31] Hambrick D C, Macmillan I C. Asset parsimony-managing assets to manage profits[J]. Sloan Management Review, 1984, 25(2): 67-74.
[32] Soliman M. Using industry-adjusted du pont analysis to predict future profitability and returns[D]. University of Michigan, 2004.
[33] White Roderick E. Generic business strategies, organizational context and performance: an empirical investigation[J]. Strategic Management Journal, 1986, 7(3): 217-231.
[34] Zeithaml C P, Fry L W. Contextual and strategic differences among mature businesses in four dynamic performance situations[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 1984, 27(4): 841-860.
[35] Tirole J . The theory of industrial organization[M]. Cambridge, MA: The Press of Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 1988. 375.
[36] Rumelt R P, Schendel D, Teece D J. Strategic management and economics[J]. Strategic Management Journal, January, 1991,12(10): 1002-1025.
[37] Saloner G, Modelling, Game Model, and strategic management[J]. Strategic Management Journal, 1991, 12(4): 119-136.
[38] Ormanidhi O, Stringa O. Porter's model of generic competitive strategies: an insightful and convenient approach to firms' analysis[J]. Business Economics, 2008(7): 55-64.
[39] Ho T H, Weigelt K. Game theory and competitive strategy.//George S. Day, Reibstein, David J. Wharton on Dynamic Competitive Strategy[A]. New York: John Wiley and Sons, 1997.
[40] Besanko D, Dranove D, Shanley M. Economics of strategy[M]. John Wiley&Sons, New York, 2000.
[41] 洪江涛,陈俊芳.企业动态竞争战略选择的微分博弈分析[J].上海交通大学学报,2007,41(12):1976-1979.
[42] 肖绍平,邓超.双寡头核心能力发展竞争、学习追随与核心能力均衡[J].管理评论,2011,23(4):87-96.
[43] Karnani A. Generic competitive strategies-an analytical approach[J]. Strategic Management Journal, 1984, 5(4): 367-380.
[44] Tyagi R K. Cost leadership and pricing[J]. Economics Letters, 2001, 72(2): 189-193.
[45] 陈圻,任娟.具单向替代性的双寡头厂商Nash均衡从业战略模型[J].系统工程2014,32(1): 70-76.
[46] 陈圻,陈佳.Palepu假设的Nash均衡检验[J].系统工程理论与实践,2015,35(8):1956-1967.
[47] 林芳强.基于财务分析的中国汽车制造业上市公司竞争战略识别与特征研究[D].南京航空航天大学经济与管理学院,2016.
[48] 陈圻,任娟.创新型低成本战略的科学研究纲领方法论基础[J].科学学研究,2011(3):349-58.
[49] Tang Ying-Chan, Liou Fen-May. Does firm performance reveal its own causes? the role of bayesian inference[J]. Strategic Management Journal, 2010(31): 39-57.
[50] 任娟,陈圻.基于竞争战略类型识别的中国制造业上市公司创新效率研究[J].科技管理研究,2015(3):54-58.
[51] 陈圻,任娟.Dupont-Nash从业战略识别准则和Palepu-Little假设检验[J].管理工程学报.2016(4):135-144.
[52] 林芳强,等.基于财务视角的企业竞争战略识别与检验——以华东地区汽车行业上市公司为例[J].华东经济管理,2017,31(2):78-88.
[53] Moses A, Masoud Y. Does the implementation of a combination competitive strategy yield incremental performance benefits? A New Perspective from a Transition Economy in Sub-Saharan Africa[J]. Journal of Business Research, 2008,61(3): 346-354.
[54] Przeworski A, Teune H. The Logic of Comparative Social Inquiry[M]. New York: Wiley, 1969: 22.