运筹与管理 ›› 2024, Vol. 33 ›› Issue (10): 73-79.DOI: 10.12005/orms.2024.0322

• 理论分析与方法探讨 • 上一篇    下一篇

消费者预购估值不确定风险下零售商预售模式的选择及决策

史保莉, 徐琪, 孙中苗   

  1. 东华大学 旭日工商管理学院, 上海 200051
  • 收稿日期:2022-04-13 出版日期:2024-10-25 发布日期:2025-02-26
  • 通讯作者: 徐琪(1963-),女,浙江台州人,博士,教授,博士生导师,研究方向:供应链管理,电子商务,运作管理等。
  • 作者简介:史保莉(1994-),女,安徽阜阳人,博士研究生,研究方向:电子商务与供应链管理。
  • 基金资助:
    国家社会科学基金资助项目(21BGL014);国家自然科学基金重点项目(71832001);中央高校基本科研业务费专项资金项目、东华大学研究生创新基金项目(CUSF-DH-D-2021063)

Choice and Decision of Retailer's Pre-sale Model at the Risk of Uncertainty in Consumer Pre-purchase Valuation

SHI Baoli, XU Qi, SUN Zhongmiao   

  1. Glorious Sun School of Business and Management, Donghua University, Shanghai 200051, China
  • Received:2022-04-13 Online:2024-10-25 Published:2025-02-26

摘要: 本文考虑风险厌恶的策略型消费者面临预购估值不确定风险情形,探讨允许全额退款的折价预售、定金膨胀和“线下体验+预售”三种预售模式的选择和优化决策问题。研究表明:零售商预售模式的选择与体验店的建设成本和缺货率相关。当消费者和零售商因退货产生的成本较高时,零售商采取折价预售,且制定相对较高的预售价格来弥补因消费者退货产生的损失;当体验店建设成本较高时,零售商应选择允许全额退款的折价预售模式或定金膨胀预售模式,特别是缺货率较高时,零售商应该选择定金膨胀预售模式;当体验店建设成本较低时,零售商应选择“线下体验+预售”的销售模式。

关键词: 折价预售, 定金膨胀, “线下体验+预售”, 风险厌恶, 策略型消费者

Abstract: With the development of e-commerce, pre-sale, as an effective sales strategy, has been widely used in retail industries such as new products and short-life cycle products. However, pre-sales are a double-edged sword for consumers. Although pre-sales can provide consumers with the opportunity to pre-order products, and pre-sales are usually accompanied by some preferential activities, during the pre-sale period, consumers have not yet seen the physical product or experienced the real product. Consumers are faced with the risk of uncertainty in the valuation of pre-ordered products, which will further affect consumer pre-order behavior and retailers' revenue. In order to reduce the impact of uncertainty in the valuation of pre-sale products and improve consumer satisfaction, many retailers provide full refund services for pre-sale products or provide consumers with some new pre-sale models, such as deposit inflation and the offline experience+pre-sale mode. These new pre-sale models are designed to solve consumers' valuation uncertainty, so that consumers can wait until the valuation is confirmed before completing the pre-order order, reducing consumers' pre-order risk. Therefore, how to choose an appropriate pre-sale model and determine the optimal pre-sale price and order quantity is an important issue that retailers face when formulating pre-sale strategies.
This paper considers the current mode of deposit inflation and offline experience+pre-sale adopted by retailers in online pre-sales, and the situation where retailers provide returns for pre-ordered products at the risk of uncertain valuation of consumers' pre-orders. Aiming at the retailer's pre-sale period and current sale period, this paper discusses the choice of three pre-sale models for retailers when consumer valuation is uncertain. The first is a discounted pre-sale that provides a full refund service; the other two models are for consumers to complete the pre-order after the valuation is confirmed: deposit inflation and the “offline experience+pre-sale” model. And we analyze the retailer's optimal pre-sale price and order quantity decision-making problem. The consumer's purchase process is described by constructing the consumer utility function, and the retailer's profit model is constructed for three situations, and the optimal order quantity and pre-sale price of the retailer under the three pre-sale modes are solved by using the newsboy model and K-T conditions. And we analyze the impact of consumer risk aversion, retailer's net loss due to product returns and consumer experience product trouble cost on retailer's pre-sale decision and pre-sale model selection, so as to provide guidance for retailers to formulate product pre-sale strategies.
 The research shows that consumers and retailers have high costs due to returns, compared with deposit inflation and the offline experience+pre-sale sales model. When a retailer implements a discounted pre-sale model that allows returns, it should set a relatively high pre-sale price to make up for the losses caused by consumers' returns. The choice of the retailer's pre-sale mode is related to the construction cost of the experience store and the product out-of-stock rate during the regular sale period. There is a threshold for the construction cost of an experience store. If the retailer adopts the offline experience+pre-sale model and the construction cost of the experience store is high, the retailer should abandon the offline experience+pre-sale sales model and choose a discounted pre-sale model that allows full refunds or a deposit-inflated pre-sale model. When consumers' risk aversion is low and they don't care too much about the uncertainty of product valuation, they can pre-order online without having to experience the product. Therefore, at this time, under the offline experience+pre-sale model, retailers should lower the pre-sale price to attract consumers to pre-order. When consumers have high risk aversion, they will prefer to experience the product before purchasing the product. At this time, retailers can take the opportunity to improve the pre-sale price of the offline experience+pre-sale model to increase the gross profit margin.

Key words: discount pre-sale, deposit inflation, offline experience+pre-sale, risk aversion, strategic consumer

中图分类号: