质量约束下闭环供应链差异决策研究

doi:10.12005/orms.2022.0291

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 针对由一原始设备制造商和一独立再制商所组成的闭环供应链系统,考虑到新品质量水平对独立再制商可回收量的质量约束效应,以及新品与再制品的价格及质量竞争,分别构建了原始设备制造商领导、独立再制商领导、无领导三种不同市场结构下闭环供应链决策模型,探讨了质量约束效应对闭环供应链运营的影响。研究表明:(1)三种市场结构下,新品和再制品两者在“质量水平-价格”两维度均有所差异,且市场地位的不对等有利于产品质量水平的共同提升;(2)质量约束效应的存在会对产品的价格和质量同时产生影响;(3)再制品具有质量劣势,且质量约束效应的增强,再制品质量劣势越大;(4)市场结构的变化及质量约束效应的强弱并不会影响市场总需求量,仅仅会影响成员企业的市场份额;在大多数情况下,消费者对新品需求更为活跃。但当原始设备制造商为市场领导者时,质量约束效应低于一阈值水平时,再制品销量反而高于新品销量;(5)无论从成员个体,还是从供应链整体,原始设备制造商为领导者的市场结构最有效,且新品质量约束效应并不会影响供应链总利润,仅影响成员企业在总利润中的分成;新品质量约束效应的增强更有利于原始设备制造商利润的改善,但同时会损害独立再制商利润。

关键词: 闭环供应链, 再制造, 质量水平, 价格, 博弈模型, 质量约束

Abstract: This paper considers a closed-loop supply chain(CLSC)with an Original Equipment Manufacturer(OEM)and an independent remanufacturer (IR). OEM is a traditional manufacturing producing new product, while IR operates a reverse channel producing remanufactured product from used product recycling from customer directly. In fact, the quality of new product brought by OEM can effectively restricts the collection quantity of used product. Based on the “quality-price” dual-competition between the new products and remanufactured ones, and the quality constrainment effect, considering the three different market dominant structures(OEM-leader, IR-leader, No-leader), game models are proposed to derive the optimal quality and pricing decisions for chain members respectively, and the effect of the quality constraint on the operation of CLSC is analyzed. The results show that: (1)under the three different market structures, remanufactured products should be differentiated from new ones from the perspective of price and quality, and the chain with a leader is conductive to the improvement of product quality, whether products are new ones or remanufactured ones; (2)the existence of the quality constraint effect has an impact on the price and quality strategies simultaneously; (3)the quality of remanufactured product is inferior to that of new ones. At the same time, the enhancement of quality constraint effect leads to the quality weakness of remanufactured products greater, leaving new products to the trend of higher quality and higher price, remanufactured ones to the trend of lower quality and higher price that is harmful to the market promotion of remanufactured ones; (4)the change of market structure and the quality constraint effect have no impact on the total demand, but only the market share of chain members. Customer demand of new product is usually higher than that of remanufactured one. However, when OEM is the market leader and the quality constraint effect is lower than a threshold level, the demand of remanufactured products is higher than that of new ones; (5)the supply chain dominated by OEM is most effective from the perspective of chain member's profit and the whole supply chain's profit. The quality constraint effect has no impact on the whole supply chain's profit, but only affect the profit share between the chain members.

Key words: closed-loop supply chain, remanufacturing, quality level, price, game model, quality constraint

中图分类号:

孟丽君, 黄祖庆, 张宝友, 杨玉香, 程红亚, 扈裕晴. 质量约束下闭环供应链差异决策研究[J]. 运筹与管理, 2022, 31(9): 99-106.

MENG Li-jun, HUANG Zu-qing, ZHANG Bao-you, YANG Yu-xiang, CHEN Hong-ya, HU Yu-qing. Decision Research on Closed-loop Supply Chain Based on the Effect of Quality Constraint[J]. Operations Research and Management Science, 2022, 31(9): 99-106.

参考文献

[1] Zhu Q H, Sarkis J, Lai K H. Supply chain-based barriers for truck-engine remanufacturing in china[J]. Transportation Research Part E, 2015, 74(S): 103-117.
[2] Abbey J D, Kleber R, Souza G C, et al. The role of perceived quality risk in pricing remanufactured products[J]. Production and Operations Management, 2017, 26(1): 100-115.
[3] Taleizadeh A T, Moshtagh M S, Moon I. Pricing, product quality and collection optimization in a decentralized closed-loop supply chain with different structure: game theoretical approach[J]. Journal of Cleaner Production, 2018, 189(7): 406-431.
[4] Hassanpour A, Bagherinejad J, Bashiri M. A robust leader-follower approach for closed loop supply chain network design considering returns quality levels[J]. Computers and Industrial Engineering, 2019, 136(10): 293-304.
[5] Xie J P, Zhang W S, Liang L, et al. The revenue and cost sharing contract of pricing and servicing policies in a dual-channel closed-loop supply chain[J]. Journal of Cleaner Production, 2018, 191(8): 361-383.
[6] Samuel C N, Venkatadri U, Diallo C, et al. Robust closed-loop supply chain design with presorting, return quality and carbon emission considerations[J]. Journal of Cleaner Production, 2020, 247(2): 119086
[7] Modak N M, Modak N, Panda S, et al. Analyzing structure of two-echelon closed-loop supply chain for pricing, quality and recycling management[J]. Journal of Cleaner Production, 2018, 171(1): 512-518.
[8] Taleizadeh A A, Nima A B, Niaki S T A. A Closed-loop supply chain considering carbon reduction, quality improvement effort, and return policy under two remanufacturing scenarios[J]. Journal of Cleaner Production, 2019, 232(9): 1230-1250.
[9] Giri B C, Mondal C, Maiti T. Optimal product quality and pricing strategy for a two-period closed-loop supply chain with retailer variable markup[J]. Rairo Operations Research, 2019, 53(2): 609-626.
[10] Liao H L, Deng Q W, Shen N. Optimal remanufacture-up-to strategy with uncertainties in acquisition quality, quantity, and market demand[J]. Journal of Cleaner Production, 2019, 206(1): 987-1003.
[11] Zhang Z, Liu S, Niu B. Coordination mechanism of dual-channel closed-loop supply chains considering product quality and return[J]. Journal of Cleaner Production, 2020, 248(3): 1-17.
[12] Adem Ö, Eda K Z, Ali K P. Competitive quality choice and remanufacturing[J]. Production and Operations Management, 2014, 23(1): 48-64.
[13] 高鹏,聂佳佳,陆玉梅,等.不同市场领导下竞争型再制造供应链质量水平决策研究[J].管理工程学报,2016,30(4):187-195.
[14] 高鹏,杜建国,聂佳佳,等.消费者后悔预期对再制造供应链质量水平决策的影响[J].管理评论,2018,30(11):234-246.
[15] 聂佳佳,熊璐洁.新产品质量水平对闭环供应链再制造模式选择的影响[J].工业工程,2018,21(5):31-39,63.
[16] 聂佳佳,邓东方.再制造产品质量水平对闭环供应链回收渠道的影响[J].工业工程与管理,2014,19(1):1-7.
[17] 董乾东,李敏,姜素红.基于产品质量水平差异的闭环供应链混合回收模式[J].系统工程,2017,35(2):116-121.
[18] Taleizadeh A A, Moshtagh M S. A consignment stock scheme for closed loop supply chain with imperfect manufacturing processes, lost sales, and quality dependent return: multi levels structure[J]. International Journal of Production Economics, 2019, 217(S): 298-316.
[19] Guide J R, Li J. The potential of cannibalization of new products sales by remanufactured product[J]. Decision Science, 2010, 41(3): 547-572.
[20] 曹晓刚,郑本荣,闻卉. 基于质量水平和价格竞争的再制造系统均衡决策研究[J].控制与决策,2014,29(8):1394-1400.
[21] 曹俊,熊中楷,刘莉莎.闭环供应链中新件制造商和再制造商的价格及质量水平竞争[J].中国管理科学,2010,18(5):82-90.[22] Li Y J, Xu L, Li D H. Examining relationships between the return policy, product quality, and pricing strategy in online direct selling[J]. International Journal of Production Economics, 2013, 144(2): 451-460.
[23] Liu G, Sethi S P, Zhang J. Myopic vs far-sighted behaviors in a revenue-sharing supply chain with reference quality effects[J]. International Journal Production Research, 2016, 54(5): 1334-1357.
[24] Nobu M, Yoshiyasu Y. A note on price and quality competition between asymmetric firms[J]. European Journal of Operational Research, 2008, 187(2): 571-581.
[25] Zhang C T, Ren M L. Closed-loop supply chain coordination strategy for the remanufacture of patented products under competitive demand[J]. Applied Mathematical Modelling, 2016, 40(13-14): 6243-6255.
[26] Wang N M, He Q D, Jiang B. Hybrid closed-loop supply chains with competition in recycling and product markets[J]. International Journal of Production Economics, 2019, 217(S): 246-258.
[27] Maiti T, Giri B C. Two-way product recovery in a closed-loop supply chain with variable markup under price and quality dependent demand[J]. International Journal of Production Economics, 2017, 183(6): 259-272.