运筹与管理 ›› 2025, Vol. 34 ›› Issue (7): 147-153.DOI: 10.12005/orms.2025.0220

• 应用研究 • 上一篇    下一篇

考虑声誉约束的工业遗留污染场地治理机会主义行为防范策略

许玲燕, 万宇, 杜建国, 王为华   

  1. 江苏大学 管理学院,江苏 镇江 212013
  • 收稿日期:2023-08-10 发布日期:2025-11-04
  • 通讯作者: 许玲燕(1984-),女,江苏镇江人,教授,博士生导师,研究方向:管理系统工程,资源与环境管理。Email: xulingyan333@163.com。
  • 基金资助:
    国家自然科学基金面上项目(72174076,72174054,42171081);国家社会科学基金重点项目(22AGL028);江苏省社会科学基金重点项目(24GLA007);江苏大学应急管理学院专项科研项目(KY-A-04,KY-C-05)

Precaution Strategies of Opportunistic Behavior in Remediation of Industrial Legacy Contaminated Sites Considering Reputation Constraints

XU Lingyan, WAN Yu, DU Jianguo, WANG Weihua   

  1. School of Management, Jiangsu University, Zhenjiang 212013, China
  • Received:2023-08-10 Published:2025-11-04

摘要: 作为责任主体的工业企业在转移、搬迁后遗留的污染场地治理中往往出现瞒报、漏报污染信息与治污努力等机会主义行为,严重影响了污染场地的生态修复效果和政府治理效能,亟需对其设计科学有效的防范机制。为此,考虑当前新媒体和大数据信息时代的企业声誉传播磁场效应及社会公众参与环境治理的传播效应,构建了社会公众关注下的工业遗留污染场地治理信号博弈模型,并引入声誉机制,探讨工业企业治污行为和社会公众监查策略的变化,考察声誉约束的边界条件及机会主义行为的防范策略。研究表明:属地政府给予的治污奖金和企业自身的信息披露成本是区分不同治污努力类型工业企业的关键基础;声誉既能识别工业企业的伪装效果,又能使社会公众保持相对较低的监查和信号核查成本,有效促进了工业企业的治污积极性;一定的政府惩戒力度和社会公众监查水平也会显著提升声誉约束效果,有利于防范工业企业的机会主义行为。

关键词: 工业遗留污染场地治理, 机会主义行为, 声誉机制, 信号博弈, 防范策略

Abstract: In recent years, with the continuous advancement of industrialization and urbanization in China, a large number of industrial enterprises have been relocated and transferred due to industrial transfer, industrial structure adjustment and upgrading etc. Thus, many industrial contaminated sites require timely remediation and restoration to reduce environmental and social risks. However, as the subject of liability, industrial enterprises have been involved in many problems in the process of their legacy contaminated sites remediation, especially a problem with the industrial enterprises' opportunistic behavior which cannot be totally forbidden. Then, the governance of industrial enterprises' opportunistic behavior has attracted great attention from government departments and researchers. Meanwhile, insufficient government regulation and information asymmetry have been the main causes of opportunism, making it difficult to ensure the effectiveness of legacy contaminated sites remediation and the efficiency of government governance. As such, it is urgent to design a scientific and effective mechanism to prevent industrial enterprises' opportunistic behavior.
Therefore, considering the magnetic field effect of corporate reputation transmission in the new media and big data information era, and the communication effect of public participation in environmental governance, this paper constructs a signal game model for chemical legacy contaminated sites remediation under public attention. Then the reputation mechanism is adopted to explore the variations in industrial enterprises' pollution control and public supervision. The effective conditions of reputation mechanism and the prevention strategies for opportunistic behavior are also discussed.
The research shows that there are three main factors which influence the equilibrium strategy in the process of game between the public and industrial enterprises. First, pollution control bonus given by the local government and information disclosure cost of the enterprises are the key foundations to distinguish different types of pollution control efforts from industrial enterprises. Second, the reputation mechanism could not only identify the camouflage effect of industrial enterprises but also enable the public to maintain relatively low supervision costs and signal verification costs, effectively promoting the enthusiasm of industrial enterprises in pollution control. Third, a certain degree of government discipline and public supervision could significantly improve the reputation restraint effect. According to these conclusions, some suggestions are put forward to prevent the industrial enterprises' opportunistic behavior. First, the local government can set a reasonable range of pollution control bonus and strengthen corresponding punishment mechanism. Second, the public can adjust the information disclosure cost of industrial enterprises by increasing the frequency of supervision. Besides, a blacklist and whitelist system for industrial relocation enterprises should be established to expand the impact of reputation effect. Finally, multiple measures should be taken to enhance the enthusiasm and recognition of public attention and supervision.
The article has enriched the research perspective of the impact of reputation effect on the motivation for industrial enterprises' opportunistic behavior and the strategy of public supervision, but there are also some limitations. For example, this study simplifies the types of pollution control from industrial enterprises and the types of signals, without an in-depth analysis of more types of game players involved in pollution control. In addition, a further exploration of how the relationship between the qualities of information disclosure affecting the model equilibrium solution is also required to taken.

Key words: industrial legacy contaminated sites remediation, opportunistic behavior, reputation mechanism, signaling game, precaution strategies

中图分类号: