运筹与管理 ›› 2025, Vol. 34 ›› Issue (4): 177-184.DOI: 10.12005/orms.2025.0127

• 应用研究 • 上一篇    下一篇

过度自信对制造商入驻电商平台模式的影响研究

杨家权1, 孙莹1, 苏加福1,2, 何鹏1, 黄依霞1   

  1. 1.重庆工商大学 电子商务及供应链系统重庆市重点实验室,重庆 400067;
    2.泰国格乐大学 国际学院,曼谷 10220
  • 收稿日期:2023-04-11 发布日期:2025-07-31
  • 通讯作者: 杨家权(1988-),男,重庆人,博士,副教授,硕士生导师,研究方向:平台供应链管理。Email: yangjiaquan@ctbu.edu.cn
  • 基金资助:
    重庆市社会科学规划项目(2021NDYB060);重庆市教育委员会人文社会科学研究项目(24SKGH135);重庆市教育委员会科学技术研究项目(KJQN202000820);国家社会科学基金资助项目(22CGL056);国家自然科学基金资助项目(72101039)

Impact of Overconfidence on Mode of Manufacturers Entering E-commerce Platform

YANG Jiaquan1, SUN Ying1, SU Jiafu1,2, HE Peng1, HUANG Yixia1   

  1. 1. Chongqing Key Laboratory of Electronic Commerce & Supply Chain System, Chongqing Technology and Business University, Chongqing 400067, China;
    2. International College, Krirk University, Bangkok 10220, Thailand
  • Received:2023-04-11 Published:2025-07-31

摘要: 针对一个电商平台和一个制造商组成的平台供应链,刻画制造商对市场规模的过度自信,研究过度自信对制造商入驻电商平台模式的影响。研究发现:(1)制造商完全理性时总能入驻电商平台,而过度自信时不一定能入驻电商平台;(2)只有佣金比例较小的电商平台愿意同时提供代销和分销模式,且要求制造商为完全理性或自信程度较低;(3)随着佣金比例降低,制造商入驻电商平台的最优模式从分销转代销,且过度自信制造商转变入驻模式的门槛更高;(4)过度自信制造商选择的入驻模式可能是共赢、单赢或者双输的结果,而完全理性制造商选择的入驻模式则不可能是双输的结果。最后,数值仿真发现,当过度自信制造商选择代销模式时,其感知利润和实际利润的偏离程度更低。

关键词: 平台供应链, 入驻模式, 过度自信, 感知利润

Abstract: With the rapid development of platform economy, consumers, either young or old, have been embracing online shopping. Due to the increasing number of online consumers, both the upstart and leading manufacturers have been jumping on e-commerce platforms to sell their products to consumers. When manufacturers enter an e-commerce platform, an increasingly important issue is whether their products should be sold through the agency selling or the reselling mode. Under the agency selling mode, the e-commerce platform acts as an intermediary, charging a percentage of commission to the manufacturer and allowing the manufacturer to sell the product directly to the consumers (e.g. manufacturers open flagship stores on e-commerce platforms). Under the reselling mode, the e-commerce platform plays the role of a retailer, wholesaling products from the manufacturer and reselling them to consumers (e.g. self-operated flagship store of e-commerce platform). The key difference between the two modes is that the manufacturer charges the retail price under the agency selling mode and the e-commerce platform sets the retail price under the reselling mode.
In contrast with the extant entry mode selection that typically considers completely rational manufacturers, the entry strategy of overconfident manufacturers is explored. Overconfidence, distinguished from complete rationality, is a psychological term that refers to people showing excessive optimism and confidence in their own abilities and predictions about the future. According to the psychological studies, the psychological trait of overconfidence is common in humans. Furthermore, economic research also confirms that business managers are more likely to exhibit overconfident behavior. In fact, many important business decisions, especially about entering an existing market, are made under the impact of the behavior of overconfidence. For example, when manufacturers enter the online consumer market, they are often overconfident about the size of the market for their products. In this context, the entry mode selection of overconfident manufacturers settling in the e-commerce platform is well worth exploring.
Aiming at a platform supply chain consisting of a manufacturer and an e-commerce platform, we propose the case in which the manufacturer is overconfident in the market size, establish the condition under which the platform offers both the agency selling and reselling modes, and study the impact of overconfidence on the mode of manufacturers entering the e-commerce platform. The results show that: (1)If and only if both the platform's commission ratio and the manufacturer's overconfidence are sufficiently low, the platform will offer both the agency selling and reselling modes for the overconfident manufacturer to choose. (2)When the commission ratio is relatively high (low), the overconfident manufacturer will choose the reselling (agency selling) mode; when the commission ratio is moderate, the overconfident manufacturer will choose the reselling (agency selling) mode if its overconfidence is relatively high (low). (3)The mode selected by the overconfident manufacturer can be either a win-win, win-lose, or lose-lose scenario, however the mode selected by the completely rational manufacturer cannot be a lose-lose scenario. (4)By comparing the mode choice strategies of perfectly rational and overconfident manufacturers, it is found that perfectly rational manufacturers can always enter e-commerce platforms, while overconfident manufacturers may not be able to enter e-commerce platforms with larger commission ratios; as the commission ratio decreases, the optimal mode of manufacturers' entry into e-commerce platforms is shifted from reselling to agency selling, and the bar for shifting to a different mode is higher for overconfident manufacturers. That is, if and only if both the platform's commission ratio is moderate and the manufacturer's overconfidence is sufficiently high, the overconfident and completely rational manufacturers will choose a different mode to enter the e-commerce platform. Finally, a numerical simulation suggests that the perceived profit of the overconfident manufacturer is always higher than the real profit it obtains, and their deviation degree is higher (lower) under the reselling (agency selling) mode.
Future research could explore two main directions: (1)extending the single-manufacturer framework to multiple manufacturers to examine the entry mode selection for the entrant; (2)investigating manufacturer over-pessimism as a counterpart to the current overconfidence analysis.

Key words: platform supply chain, entry mode, overconfidence, perceived profit

中图分类号: